Security team: who leads it, and whom do you hire next?

Within 30 days, have management appoint a head of security or information security officer (ISB) in writing, with a deputy and a direct line to the managing directors, outside IT operations. Then hire in the order your risks need, describe roles with ECSF profiles, and buy work that can't keep a person busy.

Reviewed
Next review
Version
1.0
Written for
Managing directors, heads of security and IT leads who also own security, in small and mid-size companies and regulated organizations

If you only do five things

  1. Appoint one owner in writing.

    Have management appoint a head of security or ISB, a deputy and their authority in a minuted decision. ENISA counts appointments, job descriptions and proof of competence as evidence for digital providers1.

  2. Give them a direct line to management.

    Digital providers need at least one person reporting directly to the management body2. The BSI advises German NIS2 managers to confirm the ISB or CISO line early3.

  3. Keep oversight out of IT operations.

    The BSI advises against placing the ISB in the IT department4. Security engineering can sit in IT; the person who checks it shouldn't.

  4. Give every security role a deputy.

    ENISA advises a deputy for each security role where possible1. Let the deputy run the monthly report while the lead is away.

  5. Hire for your top risk, buy the rest.

    Buy what specialists do a few days a year: penetration tests, forensics, 24/7 monitoring. ENISA's 2025 respondents named finding skilled candidates as the top hiring barrier, at 45%6.

Hire in this order

With the European Cybersecurity Skills Framework (ECSF) profile10 and closest NICE work role13. Small companies stop after step 1 and buy the rest.

  1. Head of security or ISB.

    ECSF Chief Information Security Officer, with information security officer as an alternative title; NICE Executive Cybersecurity Leadership. Owns strategy, policy, the ISMS and risk reporting.

  2. Security engineer.

    ECSF Cybersecurity Implementer; NICE Systems Security Analysis. Owns identity, endpoint and cloud controls with IT.

  3. Detection and response lead.

    ECSF Cyber Incident Responder; NICE Incident Response. Runs the MDR contract and incident plan. Detection and response topped ENISA's 2025 skills list6.

  4. Risk and compliance.

    ECSF Cybersecurity Risk Manager; NICE Cybersecurity Policy and Planning. Runs the risk register, regulatory evidence and customer questionnaires.

  5. Architect or deputy head.

    ECSF Cybersecurity Architect; NICE Cybersecurity Architecture. Reviews project designs and deputizes for the head.

Where the head of security reports

  • Report to the CEO or managing director. A CRO or COO also works if they don't run IT. In ENISA's 2021 survey, its latest to ask, 56% of heads of information security reported to the CEO or board, 29% to the CIO or an IT executive and 14% to risk management9.
  • Under a CIO, write safeguards down. The BSI sees an active admin as ISB as a likely conflict of interest4. Grant what the BSIG grants federal ISBs: a direct right to report to the top, and no removal or disadvantage for doing the job15.
  • Separate admin work from oversight. Digital providers must segregate conflicting duties; micro entities may compensate with management oversight or more logging2. A reviewer should be outside the line of authority under review1. The operating model sheet covers the three lines.

How big the team should be

  • About one in ten IT staff work on security. The median share was 10.6% in ENISA's 2025 survey, the lowest yet6, with a German median of 9.4%7. Most respondents were large organizations6, so treat it as a cross-check, not a target.
  • Operations takes the largest share. In ENISA's 2023 survey, operations held 40% of security staff, architecture and engineering 23%, governance and risk 21% and audit and compliance 16%8.
  • Outsource operations, not governance. 57% of those organizations used the most contractors in operations, only 9% in governance and risk; contractors were a median 20% of security staff8.
  • Count the work, not the ratio. List recurring tasks with hours per month, and make sure two trained people can do each one, in-house or at a provider.

ISB and data protection officer

  • The BSIG requires an ISB only of federal bodies. With a deputy, independent reporting and protection from being penalized for the job15. Copy that into your ISB's appointment.
  • The ISB protects all information. In the BSI's model, the ISB steers the security process, advises management and joins major projects, for paper as well as IT4.
  • The DPO monitors data protection law. They take no instructions on it, report to the top and may be external16. Germany requires one from 20 people regularly processing personal data by computer, or for processing that needs a DPIA17.
  • Keep the two apart. Grundschutz++ calls DPO versus ISB a conflict to avoid5. The CJEU sees a possible conflict of interest when other duties have the DPO set the purposes and means of processing18.

A virtual or fractional CISO

  • It fits part-time work. Use one below about 250 staff, for a first ISMS or between hires. The BSI sees an external ISB as useful in small companies4; digital providers may give security roles to external parties2.
  • Keep accountability and control in-house. Responsibility and oversight can't be delegated, the BSI says3. Keep an internal coordinator, risk acceptance, the decision to report an incident, admin and emergency credentials, and the asset and supplier lists.
  • Write the contract for the bad day. Name the person and a deputy, hours per month, incident response time, deliverables, document ownership and exit handover. See the third-party risk sheet.
  • Don't hire your IT provider for it. It would check its own work1.

Hiring and keeping security staff

  • Expect a skills gap. In ISC2's survey, 59% had critical or significant skills needs, up from 44%14. ENISA found 94% of SMEs struggling to attract security staff6.
  • Test problem solving, not tool names. Hiring managers in ISC2's survey ranked problem solving, teamwork and communication above any technical skill14. Use a work sample from your own environment.
  • Treat certificates as one filter. Digital providers must check qualifications, for example by references, vetting, certifications or written tests2. ENISA lists certifications mapped to ECSF profiles12.
  • Fund training and the time for it. In ENISA's 2023 survey, 47% had no specific security training budget8; in 2025, workload, training and career steps topped the retention problems6. Budget five protected days a year each.

What changed in 2026

  • German duties apply. Since 6 December 2025, BSIG § 38 has management implement and oversee the measures15. The BSI's new curriculum recommends confirming the ISB or CISO line within 2 to 6 weeks of the first training3.
  • Grundschutz++ names the conflicts. BSI-Standard 300-1 of 20 October 2026 asks for roles with defined qualifications and no IT lead versus ISB or DPO versus ISB conflicts5.
  • Germany plans to drop its national DPO rule. On 4 December 2025, federal and state leaders agreed the federal government will propose repealing BDSG § 38(1) by the end of 202619. It still applies17.
  • The role catalogs are moving. NICE v2.2.0 added a supply chain risk role in April 202613. ENISA plans to consult on a revised ECSF with proficiency levels at the end of 202611. Map to the current 12 profiles now.

What you can skip

  • A full-time CISO before there's a full-time job. Below about 100 staff, let a part-time ISB with a deputy, an IT provider and MDR cover it.
  • An in-house 24/7 SOC. A few analysts can't staff round-the-clock shifts. Buy MDR; see the SOC and MDR sheet.
  • One hire per ECSF profile. The 12 profiles describe work, not headcount.
  • Certificates as the first filter. Much of today's workforce came from other jobs through upskilling, ENISA notes6. Screen with a work sample.

Mistakes that cost the most

  • Making the only admin the ISB. They would judge their own work. If nobody else fits, buy an external ISB.
  • One person who knows everything. When they leave, contacts, admin paths and open risks go too. Have the deputy work from the runbooks twice a year.
  • A title without time, budget or mandate. Security roles need qualified people with enough resources, the BSI says4. Put hours, budget and decision rights in writing.

What this looks like at your size

Small team, no security staff

  • Name an ISB with at least one day a week for the role, and a deputy. Not the only admin.
  • If nobody fits, buy an external ISB and keep a managing director as the internal owner.
  • Use an external DPO where you need one.

Growing, with IT or security staff

  • Make the first full-time hire a head of security who reports to a managing director.
  • Add a security engineer, then a detection and response lead who runs the MDR contract.
  • Write job descriptions against ECSF profiles.

Enterprise or regulated

  • Have the CISO report to the CEO or a board member who doesn't run IT.
  • Under DORA, keep ICT risk control independent20.
  • German median in ENISA's 2025 survey: 19 security FTEs, contractors included7.